-->

No Trunks, Says Palaeontologist

Posted by: Loren Coleman on July 15th, 2008

In my never-ending quest to give both sides of various intellectually stimulating issues, here is part two of Monday’s discussion on whether or not Mokele-Mbembe, if discovered, might be found to have a trunk.

Naish with skull

University of Portsmouth vertebrate palaeontologist and science writer Darren Naish (above) has a contrary opinion to that of the one highlighted here by reconstruction artist Bill Munns yesterday, on whether or not trunks existed on sauropods and a variety of other fossil animals.

brachiosaurus trunk

For the sauropods, Naish emails me this comment about Munns’ images (one, shown above) and the pro-trunk theory:

“Very cool. But the palaeontological community votes emphatically no on trunks in sauropods - recent studies of blood vessel patterns, predictions about skull musculature, and brain anatomy all confirm that none of the anatomy required for a trunk was present. It was never a good idea. Also, Munns seems unaware of recent work showing that the actual soft-tissue nostrils of sauropods were not located in the bony nares, but further down the snout and in a more ‘typical’ position for a tetrapod.”

Naish passes along that some of the relevant technical publications are:

Knoll, F., Galton, P. M. & Lopez-Antonanzas, R. 2006. “Paleoneurological evidence against a proboscis in the sauropod dinosaur Diplodocus.” Geobios 39, 215-221.

Witmer, L. M. 2001. “Nostril position in dinosaurs and other vertebrates and its significance for nasal function.” Science 293, 850-853.

Okay, no trunks on dinosaurs, in Darren Naish’s opinion, but what about those speculated for fossil mammals?

Schleich glyptodont

Schleich company’s glyptodont.

Darren's Toys

In talking about the Glyptodon model above, Naish writes:

“Schleich obviously opted not to follow Gillette & Ray’s (1981) idea (earlier proposed by Senechal in 1865) that glyptodonts had a short tapir-like proboscis: so far as I can tell, these authors favoured the idea of a proboscis simply because they thought that the neck morphology of glyptodonts would have prevented the mouth from reaching the ground, ergo a proboscis must have existed. I’m not convinced: glyptodont skulls lack the features present in living mammals that possess proboscides… but more on this another time.”

gillette-ray-trunky-glyptodont.jpg

On the possible presence of proboscides in glyptodonts, Naish did end up covering this recently, here. He says, in part:

“Some sclerocalyptine glyptodonts had particularly large, strongly pneumatised fronto-nasal sinuses that gave their nasal regions a massively bulbous appearance (this is particularly prominent in species of the Pliocene-Holocene sclerocalyptine Sclerocalyptus). Zurita et al. (2005) argued that this was an adaptation for the cold, arid conditions experienced by these animals, particularly by the Middle and Late Pleistocene Argentinean forms. This idea of glyptodonts living alongside llamas and other cold-adapted mammals in cool, dry climates is a marked contrast to the idea promoted by some that they were animals of humid wetlands, but as is so often the case it seems that glyptodonts were more diverse, and more adaptable, than stereotype allows. Incidentally, the bulbous nasal regions of the Sclerocalyptus species really don’t look at all consistent with the presence of a trunk.”

mamif1.jpg

Sclerocalyptus (reconstrucción). Museo de La Plata.

big glyptodont

Parapropalaehoplophorus septentrionalis.

So, where does that leave us with regard to the proboscides of macraucheniid litopterns, you might naturally ask? When I directly inquired of Naish’s thoughts about the trunk that is so often shown on the model (directly below) of the camel-like Macrauchenia, which we have discussed before, he replied:

Darren's Toys

“I had to think hard about Macrauchenia when supervising reconstructions for a kid’s book a while ago, and I can’t say that I am impressed with the evidence for a trunk: so far as I can recall, it actually lacks the muscle attachment sites present in living mammals that have trunks. I…have a long article on them in preparation….I have yet to make up my mind.”

schleich_macrauchenia.gif

Will Naish crush the childhood memories, past and future, of thoughts about the beautifully and strangely trunked Macrauchenia? Only time will tell.

bullyland_mastodon.jpg

Munns and Naish, however, are able to be in agreement, at least, that mastodons, mammoths and other fossil elephants had trunks. :-)
mammoth replica

the-new-deinotherium.JPG

Others are still reviewing this entire area. The old H. Osborn 1910 reconstruction of Deinotherium has been revived (as seen above) by Markov et al. (Markov, G. N.; Spassov, N.; and Simeonovski, V. “A reconstruction of the facial morphology and feeding behavior of the deinotheres.” The World of Elephants, International Congress, Rome 2001).

According to Emile’s good blog posting on this, from a study of the skull’s shape, Markov et al. deduced that Deinotherium apparently had a short, tapir-like snout hanging over its descending lower jaw.

tapir-asian-perseus-gray-plastic-animal-t146m.jpg

Even today, Munns and Naish would be forced to agree, due to reality, that among various unique animals, trunks are represented on the likes of modern elephant seals, elephants and the routinely strange tapirs!

tapir replica
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
museum logo

Since June 26th, over 150 different people have contributed (averaging a bit over $30 each), and the donation drive got off to a great start. Even two benefactors, at $1000 and $1050 pitched in, but donations have dropped off to almost zero since July 3rd.

Please donate to the museum, and remember you may directly send a check, money order, or, if outside the USA, an international postal money order made out the “International Cryptozoology Museum,” via snail mail to

International Cryptozoology Museum
c/o Loren Coleman
PO Box 360
Portland, ME 04112

Or with the click of a button, electronically contribute.

Please “Save The Museum”! Easy-to-use donation buttons are now available here or merely by clicking the blank button below, which takes you to a donation site without your being a member of PayPal. Thank you, everyone!


Random Posts

Spread the Word!

Similar Phenomena:

Random Posts


6 Responses to “No Trunks, Says Palaeontologist”

  1. Lightning Orb responds:

    I’ll admit I don’t know much about the fossil structure this would require, but if the sauropods didn’t have trunks, might they have instead had smaller, inflatable bulges like a bullfrog’s gullet? Or a pair of “snorkels” on the top of the head, like the strange horn-like appendages depicted in some loch monster sketches?

  2. cryptidsrus responds:

    Good post, Loren!!!

  3. Bill Munns responds:

    Regarding this article, I commend Loren for presenting both sides of this discussion.

    I would like to remind one and all my ideas are mere hypothesis, and based on considerations of biomechanical functionality. I happen to have great confidence in the evolutionary mechanism of nature to produce successful working anatomical features on prehistoric life, and in that regard, all prior descriptions of the sauropods with nares at the top of the head are poor biomechanical designs. That is why I feel the topic should remain open to discussion and more effective biomechanical designs need to be considered.

    Bill

  4. Munnin responds:

    Fascinating stuff from Mr. Munns and Mr. Naish both! Thanks for a great post. When I look at the model of the Macrauchenia above, I can’t help thinking that, if the trunk were shortened a bit, the resulting effect might offer a resemblance to the face of the Saiga antelope (Saiga tatarica).

  5. Endroren responds:

    Fantastic post! This sort of willingness to explore various sides of an idea is what I love about this site. Thank you!

  6. sschaper responds:

    When I think about the avian affinities of even the sauropods, could there have been keratinous material like a bill for making calls and displays that doesn’t fossilize, and that explain the position - and lack of connections for muscles, of the nares?



Leave your comments

You must be logged in to post a comment.

|Top | Content|


Donate Today

Advertisement




|Top | FarBar|

india generic viagra on line sales Viagra Soft Tabs phizer stock and viagra infertility? Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Is Viagra Safe For Women viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra And Nitrous Oxide cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viagra Vs Cialis "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Viagra For Sale herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Forum Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Does Medicaid Cover Viagra Kentucky taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Buy Viagra Online In Uk generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Viagra Ukonly viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Recreational Use Of Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. viagra patent expire Super Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Ecstacy And Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! U 2241 Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Discount Viagra herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Overnight Shipping Fedex Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra andnot generic
T 84 Viagra
taking viagra woman "cheap generic kamagra kamagra uk viagra" Viagra Cartoons generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Viagra From India viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums 10-minute Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Viagra Buy viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra Sideffects cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viagra Options "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Historic Price Viagra herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Premature Ejaculation Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Cheapest Viagra Ever taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Online Overnight Delivery generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" U 2899 Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Buy Viagra In London England Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Viagra Cheap Buy Online viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Cialis Compared To Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viagra On-line "can i take viagra" viagra how does it work Diabetes And Viagra herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Mail Order Viagra In Uk Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Ordering Viagra taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Hearing Loss generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Buy Viagra Online 35008 Buy viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Viagra Sources Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. viagra patent expire Alternative To Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra Make It Bigger cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Watermelon Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Viagra On Line herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Funny Picture Viagra Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? How Long Does Viagra Last taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Next Day Delivery generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Buy Viagra Online viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Viagra Next Day Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Marajuana And Viagra
viagra anxiety?

taking viagra after the expiration date

U 3312 Viagra Cialis

cheap gerneric viagra

generic viagra for under $50.00 Who Is Viagra Target Market "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Viagra Boosts Chemical Cuddle Performance herbal viagra forums "smooth muscle piperazine viagra" Buy Viagra Without Prescription Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Find Search Pages Years Viagra Edinburgh taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra And Sperm Count
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
california phentermine network dish viagra Sublingual Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Recreational Viagra Use Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Buy Viagra With Pay Pal viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra Effects On Women

cheap gerneric viagra

generic viagra in british columbia Suppliers Of Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Purchase Viagra Online herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Women Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra Soft taking viagra woman
cheap gerneric viagra
Cialis Levia And Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! california phentermine network dish viagra Money Order Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Does Viagra Really Work Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263.
Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Viagra For Sale Without A Prescription viagra anxiety? taking viagra after the expiration date Shelf Life Of Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Buy Viagra Australian "can i take viagra" viagra how does it work Viagra In The Water herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Online At Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Ladies Viagra taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Generic Soft Tab generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" How Do Viagra Segment The Market viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Better Than Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. File Viewtopic T 21508 Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra Information cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viagra Sex "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Order Cheap Viagra Fas herbal viagra forums "smooth muscle piperazine viagra" Viagra Suppliers In The Uk Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? How To Get Viagra taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Using Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Generic Viagra Mexico viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Canada Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Q Viagra Meta viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Buy Viagra Online Without Prescription cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Purchase Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Viagra Without A Prescription herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Versus Cialis Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra From Usa taking viagra woman
cheap gerneric viagra
Viagra Info generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! california phentermine network dish viagra Viagra Discussion viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Viagra Picture Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. How To Make Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Splitting Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Cheap Viagra Nz "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Dangers Of Viagra herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. What Is Viagra Used For Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra Uk 32 taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Covered By Insurance generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Negative Effects Of Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Gernic Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Is Viagra Dangerous viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Herbal Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Cheapest Viagra In Uk "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Mail Order Viagra herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Can Viagra Cause Restless Leg Syndrome Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Buy Viagra In England taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra 100mg generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Cialis Versus Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums 18 Takes Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Male Quadriplegic Using Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Buy Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viagra As Ergogenic Aid "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Natural Viagra Substitutes herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Chewable Viagra Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Natural Alternatives To Viagra taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra
Non Prescription Viagra
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! california phentermine network dish viagra Does Watermelon Have Viagra Effect viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Long Term Side Effects Of Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. viagra patent expire Viagra Sale viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman How Much Does Viagra Cost cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Discount Viagra Online "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Online Viagra Store herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Discount Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra Larger Forever taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Lawyer Ohio generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Viagra Perscription Online viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Viagra Commercial Canyon Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Aspirin And Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra Blood Pressure cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Robin Williams Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Buy Viagra Australia herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Potenzmittel Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Purchasing Viagra In The United Kingdom taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Benefits generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Viagra Experiences viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Took 100mg Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Mexico Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Legal Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viagra Patent Up "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Buy Sublingual Viagra Online herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Timing Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Buying Viagra Online taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Equivalent generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Buying Viagra In Uk viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Buy Generic Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Can Women Take Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra Paypal cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viagra Price Comparison "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Natural Herbal Alternatives To Viagra herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Canada Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra Canadian Pharmacy taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Headache generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Pharmacy Ecstasy Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Watermelon And Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. viagra patent expire Viagra Japan viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra Herbal Substitute cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viagra Compounds "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Buying Viagra Online In Britain herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Mailing List Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra And Discovery taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Order Uk generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Uk Viagra Sales viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Viagra Facts Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Viagra Online Shop In Uk viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Cialis Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viagra Tablets "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Does Viagra Work herbal viagra forums "smooth muscle piperazine viagra" Viagra Wholesale Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra Uterine Thickness taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Dog Ate Viagra Tablet Any Danger generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Buy Viagra Onli viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Pfizer Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Viva Viagra Commercial viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra Forums cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viagra For Peyronies Disease "can i take viagra" viagra how does it work Watermelon Rind Viagra herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Natural Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra Stories And Pics taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Attorney Ohio generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Viagra Sverige viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Viagra Texas Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Rush Limbaugh Viagra Dominican Republic viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra Strips cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Is There A Female Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! How To Buy Viagra herbal viagra forums "smooth muscle piperazine viagra" Cialis Viagra Paypal Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra andnot generic Viagra Discounts taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Cost generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Viagra Erection Duration viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Viagra Real Mail Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Get Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra Online Price Iframe cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Buy Cheap Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Shelf Life For Viagra herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Cheap Herbal Viagra Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra andnot generic Q Buy Viagra Online taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Russian Viagra Women News generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" U 5672 Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Viagra Discount 800 Number Customer Service Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Viagra Racing Heart viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Non Presciption Viagra Replacements cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viva Viagra Wild Horses "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Viagra In Mexico herbal viagra forums "smooth muscle piperazine viagra" Qry Viagra Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra Or Cialis taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Serotonin Viagra Sale generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Viagra Gel viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Viagra Substitutes Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263.
viagra patent expire Cheapest Viagra Substitute Sildenafil viagra anxiety? taking viagra after the expiration date Topic 3642 Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Side Effects Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how does it work Herbal Viagra Reviews herbal viagra forums "smooth muscle piperazine viagra" Viagra Suppliers Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Discounted Viagra taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra
Viagra Illegal Phillipines
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! california phentermine network dish viagra Wholesale Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Female Use Of Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Effects Of Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman

Side Affects Of Viagra

cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra in british columbia Viagra Alternatives "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Viagra Complaints herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra And Hearing Loss Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Online Viagra taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra
Buy Viagra Online At
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! california phentermine network dish viagra Can Viagra Be Used By Women viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums European Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. viagra patent expire Where To Buy Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Washington Post Viagra Aphganistan cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Overnight Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Can Young People Take Viagra herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Effects Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Womens Viagra taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra What Does Viagra Do To Females generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Where Can I Buy Viagra Online viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Marijuana And Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263.
Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Viagra Powerpoint Presentation viagra anxiety? taking viagra after the expiration date How To Take Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Lowest Price Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Home Made Viagra herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Snorting Viagra Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Edinburgh Uk News Viagra Site Search taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Dosing generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" To Buy Viagra How viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Viagra And High Blood Pressure Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Viagra Attorneys viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Rapid Tabs Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Generic Name Of Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Viagra Effekter Biverkningar herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Incidents Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Compare Cialis Levitra Viagra taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra For Women generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Soft Tab Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Viagra No Prior Prescription Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Buy Viagra On Line viagra anxiety?

taking viagra woman

Viagra Wikipedia cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra in british columbia Viagra Dosage "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! U 52892 Viagra herbal viagra forums "smooth muscle piperazine viagra" Viagra Cialis Levitra Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra andnot generic Viagra Ejaculation taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Buy Price Iframe generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Viagra And Alternatives viagra how it works! herbal viagra cartridge Can Women Take Mens Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Fake Viagra Prescription viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Claim Status Lawsuit For Viagra cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Uk Alternative Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Low Cost Alternatives And Viagra herbal viagra forums "smooth muscle piperazine viagra" Order Viagra Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra Online Overnight taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra And Sports generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Getting Viagra In The Philippines viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Viagra By Mail Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. On Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Cheapest Viagra Prices cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Confidential Overnight Shipping Viagra Overnight "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Viagra Sex Domination herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Dosage Viagra Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra Oral Jelly taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Coumadin And Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Vicodin Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Viagra Online No Prescription Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Generic Mexican Viagra viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Buy Cheap Viagra Soft cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Viagra Mail Order Uk "can i take viagra" viagra how does it work Generic Viagra India herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Pharmacy Viagra Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety?
Viagra And Cannabis
taking viagra woman "cheap generic kamagra kamagra uk viagra" Viagra Agonists
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
california phentermine network dish viagra Homemade Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Women Who Take Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. viagra patent expire Discount Viagra Pills viagra anxiety? taking viagra woman Viagra Size cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! Rush Limbaugh Viagra "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Cheap Viagra Online herbal viagra forums "smooth muscle piperazine viagra" Viagra Low Cost Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety?
Viagra Bon Marche
taking viagra woman "cheap generic kamagra kamagra uk viagra" Women Using Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Cialis Or Viagra viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Womans Viagra Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. viagra patent expire Viagra Games viagra anxiety?

taking viagra woman

Viagra Litigation cheap gerneric viagra generic viagra in british columbia Viagra Jelly "can i take viagra" viagra how it works!
Impotence Viagra
herbal viagra forums sildenafil viagra 2007 crohn Recreational Viagra Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra Cartoon taking viagra woman cheap gerneric viagra Viagra Logo generic viagra levitra and cialis pills! "can i take viagra" Cheapest Viagra Anywhere viagra how it works! herbal viagra forums Viagra Reviews Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263.
Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. Viagra In Manchester Uk viagra anxiety? taking viagra after the expiration date Viagra Ads

cheap gerneric viagra

generic viagra in british columbia Viagra Online No Rx "can i take viagra" viagra how it works! Apcalis Levitra Viagra herbal viagra forums Snorting viagra health snow 100mg pills price viagra 263. Viagra Falls Band Viagra patent levitra viagra patent litigation 865. viagra anxiety? Viagra Faq taking viagra woman

Attention: This is the end of the usable page!
The images below are preloaded standbys only.
This is helpful to those with slower Internet connections.