Cryptomundo » Cryptid Quagga?

Cryptid Quagga?

Posted by: Loren Coleman on December 13th, 2006

Quagga

An article in the Edmonton Journal, December 13, 2006, concerns an alleged quagga, a South Africa species with genetic links to zebras said to be extinct for over 100 years.

This specific equine has been missing for over two weeks from a farm located at Carrot Creek, a little way west of Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.

The animal seems rather unique:

The eight-year-old stallion, named Zebastian, is a brown zebra with black stripes, and its owner fears the animal’s unique looks will tempt area hunters who don’t know how special it is.

Plus…

[Patricia] O’Neil bought Zebastian seven years ago at an auction near Innisfail, thinking he was a hybrid horse.

When Zebastian fathered a foal, O’Neil said she sent his DNA for testing at the University of Phoenix. She said Zebastian has the DNA markers of a quagga zebra, a species that has been extinct for more than 100 years.

“I am sure the zoo industry and zoologists will be very interested in that finding,” Valley Zoo operations supervisor Dean Treichel said.

Treichel has been working with the zoo for 28 years and says the only Alberta zebras he is aware of live in the province’s two zoos. He is skeptical.

Update: Photographs of Zebastian have been forwarded to us. He does not exhibit the classic Quagga striping, but that of a zebra-horse hybrid.

Click on image for full-size version

The search is still on for Zebastian.

Thanks to Red Grossinger in Whitehorse, Yukon, for passing this along.

Quagga

The public domain images shown are an old photograph and a print of the known (extinct) quagga from Africa, below the new ones sent in of Zebastian.

Random Posts

This entry was posted on Wednesday, December 13th, 2006 at 7:12 pm and is filed under Breaking News, CryptoZoo News, Cryptozoology, Extinct, New Species, Out of Place. You can follow responses via our RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is not allowed.

Spread the Word!

del.icio.us Digg Furl Reddit StumbleUpon Help

Similar Phenomena:

22 Responses to “Cryptid Quagga?”

cryptohunter responds: December 13th, 2006 at 10:49 pm
Interesting. Hope they find the little guy and he turns out to be a quagga.
Equine Fan responds: December 13th, 2006 at 11:27 pm
Wow, now that would really be something if he really is part Quagga. I know there are some specialized breeding programs in the US and Africa where they are trying to bring back the Quagga or breed for its looks, though all they seem to get are mostly white Zebras with Stripes on the head, neck, and withers.

I wish there were a photo we could see of this guy. I bet he closly resembles the looks of a Zdonk, or even a Zorse, which is why she was surprised he produced a foal and had him tested, as the hybrids are unable to reproduce like mules…
Cryptonut responds: December 13th, 2006 at 11:29 pm
Hadn’t heard of the quagga before, although I have seen a lot of pics of cross bred species, like the Zorse which is what it reminded me of when I saw the first picture.

It sounds like a story worth hearing more about, but the first question that comes to mind is how does a creature like that which was naturally from South Africa (and that is supposedly extinct) happen to be on a Ranch in Canada in the first place? Then the second is that if the owner had this thing on a farm, he must surely have some pictures of it that someone can evaluate.

Maybe I’m optimistic, but I don’t think anyone would shoot that thing. It would be like seeing a bigfoot for the first time. I’ve never seen one in the flesh, but I imagine that looking at something like that would bring about all kinds of other thoughts first, and not just to shoot it for the sake of shooting it. The only thing I would shoot it with would be a camera.

Ok, so if blurry photos show up of this creature will it be a quaggablob, a blurryquagga, or?
Loren Coleman responds: December 13th, 2006 at 11:57 pm
Blobquagga, of course.
Update…photos have been found. They are not blobquaggas, but the pictures clearly show the mane, leg coloring, and location of striping do not indicate a quagga. Time to look for comparative photos of zebra x horse, and other equine x zebra hybrids.
Morgoth responds: December 13th, 2006 at 11:57 pm
So as soon as someone figures out that the animal is part cryptid it immediately dissapears and no one can find it. Is there a pattern here?
Remobec responds: December 14th, 2006 at 12:23 am
If nothing else, I bet the Quagga-restoration projects might be interested in his genes.

It is mighty fishy though. He disapears and the world hears about him. Even if her house and all her records burned down, at least there should be some evidence out there. What happened to the DNA that was being tested? And what about the foal?
Remobec responds: December 14th, 2006 at 12:34 am
He does look most unusual. I’d say the quagga-restoration folk would definitely be interested in his genes.

However, I think he’s a zebra-horse hybrid. I think I’ve heard that once in a blue moon a mule is fertile. Probably that’s the case here. He looks much more like zebra-horse hybrids than a quagga. The main difference, imo, is the white belly and legs. Quaggas have them and horse/zebra hybrids seem to lack it.

I mean, really. What’s the likelihood that an animal that’s been claimed extinct for 100 years shows up in Canada? Just about zilch.
Remobec responds: December 14th, 2006 at 12:44 am
Sorry for the multiple messages, but after further research I must recant. I’ve found that there are no documented cases of fertile MALE mules. Only fertile FEMALE mules. I’ve run out of ideas. I leave it to the experts.
Sunny responds: December 14th, 2006 at 7:07 am
Cryptonut, as much as I would like to share your optimism, the reality just doesn’t line up.

Most hunters are very conscious of bag limits and sportsmanship, and go out of their way to conserve the species so that there are more to hunt another day.

There are, however, a fair number who subscribe to the idea of “if it moves, shoot it. If it doesn’t move, shoot it anyway.”

That would be why so many hunters every year come home (well, the lucky ones, anyway) with a load of buckshot (or worse) in their person…even if they were wearing orange vests.

Here’s hoping Zebastian finds his way home soon.
cosmic monster responds: December 14th, 2006 at 9:46 am
I haven’t been hunting in years, but we always knew what we were hunting for because you can’t kill it unless it’s in season and you’ve got a license to shoot it. We never shot at horses, mules, or cows because they don’t have horse, mule, and cow season. Also, most horses, mules, and cows have an owner and if it’s not mine I’m not going to shoot it out of fear of lawsuit.

Still…
One Eyed Cat responds: December 14th, 2006 at 11:54 am
After learning of the Quagga restoration effort, after discovering Quaggas are merely an offshoot of a zebra species, (Not remembering which right now) I would have to express surprise at one comming this far so fast. it takes time to establish a breed, which is really what Quaggas are, a breed of zebra. some things are coming through, but getting the ‘new’ quaggas to breed true is a ways off yet. We will see what this fellow is. I hope he gets home soon.
Kelly responds: December 14th, 2006 at 12:10 pm
It’s a “Zorse” or a “hebra”. Doesn’t look like a Quagga to me…silly isn’t it.
kittenz responds: December 14th, 2006 at 12:12 pm
The Quagga Project would not use an animal that is part horse. They use Burchell’s Zebras only. This is obviously a zebra-horse hybrid. They are not as uncommon as one might think. Often they are even fertile. Zebras can be crossed with donkeys as well.

Some purebred horses also have faint zebra striping on the legs but never so much as this hybrid’s.

The Quagga was a subspecies of the Burchell’s (Plains) Zebra, and its coloration is much more variable than that of other zebra species. From time to time individuals of Burchell’s Zebra are born that show more quagga-like features. The Quagga Project is attempting to use these more quagga-like zebras to re-establish the type. They are meeting with some success, although they have not yet produced a zebra that looks exactly like a Quagga.

The question also remains whether a Burchell’s zebra that looks like a Quagga is indeed a Quagga. Hopefully when and if a truly quagga-like zebra is born, its DNA can be compared to that of museum specimens of Quagga to determine whether it really is a Quagga.

Much more information is available on the Quagga Project website.
raisinsofwrath responds: December 14th, 2006 at 12:30 pm
I wouldn’t be all that surprised to learn that this guy does in fact have an animal with some Quagga genetics in it. It would seem that the breeding of such an animal is not as far fetched as say a Mammoth for example.

A very interesting situation to say the least and I hope he gets his animal back as there are hunters out there that shouldn’t own a gun let alone hunt animals with one.
One Eyed Cat responds: December 14th, 2006 at 9:37 pm
Thank you kittenz, it has beeen awhile since I looked at The Quagga Project, but the timing still didn’t make sense for it to have progressed so far.

I doubt DNA would totally match unless descendants of the exact animals that first produced a Qugga are the only animals used now. Most likely newer strains of zebra are being used. I would think based on that we have no idea what lines of Zebra went into the first Quaggas.
mystery_man responds: December 15th, 2006 at 11:02 am
That’s the one thing that gets me about the Quagga Project. The quagga was a unique subspecies, but what they are doing is breeding quagga- like zebras. So even if they get one that looks excactly like a the extinct quagga, does merely looking like one constitute a revival of the species? Would these look alikes then become a stand alone subspecies, to be classified once again as quagga or would they merely be a zebra with coloration resembling a Quagga and not a recreation of the original subspecies? I tend to think that merely looking like a Quagga does not a Quagga make.
One Eyed Cat responds: December 15th, 2006 at 5:25 pm
mystery_man I think that depends on how well the animals do in wild conditions. If they survive long enough to breed on and breed true for the Qugga look, the answer may be very close to, if not truly, be yes. The first Quaggas came about without man’s help and had to survive and continue the look.
mystery_man responds: December 16th, 2006 at 9:26 am
Yeah, I see your point One Eyed Cat. But if I breed, say, a dog to look exactly like a wolf and it continues the “wolf look”, is that really a wolf? It’s still a common dog that just resembles a wolf. How far does just coloration and superficial appearance go towards being considered a revival of this species? There is more to the genetic code than mere appearance. I don’t know enough about the quagga to really make a firm stand on this, but it is my opinion that even if it survived in the wild and continued the look, it still would only be sort of an imposter. A zebra created by humans to look like a quagga.
kittenz responds: December 17th, 2006 at 3:08 pm
I don’t think you can really compare what the Quagga project is attempting to do with selective breeding for a wolf-like dog. It’s sort of like apples and oranges.

Quaggas were a naturally evolved subspecies of Burchell’s Zebra (or probably I should say Plains Zebra), while domestic dogs, even though they are thought to be primarily descended from wolves, are a man-made, hybrid species, with DNA having been introduced from many sources, including other canid species. Dogs have been selected for domestic behavioral traits for thousands of generations, and even dogs which are nearly indistinguishable from wolves in appearance are much different from wolves in behavior. I disagree with those who consider domestic dogs to be a subspecies of wolf. They are a separate species; of that I have no doubt at all.

Subspecies are still members of the same species as the parent species in every way, with some small differences brought about by isolation of smaller populations within the whole, which allows some traits to become more pronounced or slightly different than other subspecies. But they still share basically the same gene pool.

The zebras being selectively bred by the Quagga Project are unquestionably zebras. They are drawing on the same gene pool from which the original Quaggas originated. I agree that the quagga-like animal which will eventually be produced by the Quagga project will be slightly different, genetically, than the original Quagga population. But I think that it will be very close, since they are selecting entirely from within the original species.

An interesting project which parallels the Quagga project in some ways is the “recreation” of the recently extinct Tarpan horse. “Primitive” domestic breeds of horse, known to have been descended from Tarpans, were selected and bred for Tarpan characteristics. Today an animal exists that is called a Tarpan, and they have all the characteristics that were attributed to Tarpans. They are identical to the extinct Tarpans in appearance and behavior. Whether they are actually Tarpans is largely a matter of opinion.

My personal opinion is that the recreated animals should be referred to by a different name, no matter how closely they resemble the original extinct animal. The main reason I say this is that I do not feel it would be wise to become complacent about extinction. If an extinct animal could ever be cloned, as a true clone with 100% of the genetic material coming from an extinct individual, I would consider that cloned animal to be a member of the original species. But when a species or subspecies is resurrected from selective breeding of hybrid animals, or animals of other subspecies, I think it should be designated as such. For instance, Modern Quagga as opposed to True Quagga.
elizdelphi responds: December 17th, 2006 at 9:00 pm
As others have said, quaggas were simply a color pattern variant of Plains Zebra (not necessarily even a subspecies). Zebastian is definitely a zorse and not a zebra, though it’s probable he was sired by a Plains Zebra since they are the most common species used to produce zorse offspring out of horse or pony mares. So, there would be nothing mysterious about him carrying a genetic marker carried by quaggas.
mystery_man responds: December 17th, 2006 at 11:10 pm
Yes, Kittenz, I agree that wolf and dog was perhaps a bad comparison. The more I thought about it, the more I wish I didn’t post that. It was just a rhetorical question. But you do see the point I’m trying to make. These quaggas that they are breeding would not be an exact genetic match. That was the gist of what I was trying to say. Nature created the quagga subspecies and it earned its right to be genetically distinct without human intervention. Unless humans create a clone from the original DNA, then no amount of tinkering with selective breeding is going to bring the subspecies back. It’s a matter of opinion and that is my opinion. So I definately think that these new quagga should be labelled as such, not taking on the exact scientific ame of their extinct brethren.
Bob Michaels responds: April 1st, 2007 at 3:06 pm
Take a look at The Extinction Website.

Leave your comments

You must be logged in to post a comment.

|Top | Content|

Random Posts

Spread the Word!

Random Posts

22 Responses to “Cryptid Quagga?”

Leave your comments

Main Page

Join The Search

Mystery Pages

Login

Advertisement

Syndication

Donate Today

The Beyond

Advertisement

microsoft window 2000 professional oem software

microsoft office 2003 oem,

cheap software downloads,

The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6;

microsoft window 2000 professional oem software

software oem cd line business;

iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52,

software discount oem?

adobe cs2 photo shop total training

oem software bundle

"Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2"

microsoft office 2003 oem,

microsoft window 2000 professional oem software

oem software bundle

software oem cd line business;

inkjet definition oem software

adobe cs2 photo shop total training

"locate software oem files"

iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52,

adobe any cs2 from photo photo shop shop upgrade version

"how to activate reget deluxe"

microsoft office 2003 oem,

"locate software oem files"

software discount oem?

adobe cs2 photo shop total training